Dermatologist Explains: Neosporin vs. Aquaphor vs. Vaseline vs. Doctor Rogers Restore Healing Balm
What's Best For Your Skin?
As a double board-certified dermatologic surgeon, I’ve seen countless patients rely on Neosporin, Aquaphor or Vaseline for cuts, scrapes and post-procedure care. Growing up, many of us were taught that slathering Neosporin on every wound was the right thing to do. But here’s the truth: topical antibiotics like Neosporin can do more harm than good. Let’s dive into the science and explore why Doctor Rogers Restore Healing Balm or plain Vaseline are the better choices for healing skin.
The Problem with Topical Antibiotics (Like Neosporin and Polysporin)
The global topical antibiotic market was valued between $6.5–$7 billion in 2023, with projections to exceed $11 billion in the next decade. Yet, research has shown these products don’t always deliver the benefits we expect—and they come with hidden risks.
1. They Don’t Speed Up Healing
Studies consistently show that topical antibiotics like Neosporin (containing neomycin) and Polysporin (containing bacitracin) don’t heal wounds faster than simpler alternatives:
- A randomized trial of 20 laser wound patients found no difference in redness, swelling or healing between Neosporin/Polysporin and Aquaphor. However, antibiotics caused more burning and allergic reactions (PubMed).
- In a larger study of 922 surgical patients, bacitracin showed no advantage over plain Vaseline (white petrolatum) in preventing infection or speeding healing. Vaseline had zero allergic reactions, while bacitracin caused reactions in 0.9% of cases (PubMed).
2. They’re Common Allergens
Topical antibiotics are notorious for causing allergic reactions, some severe:
- Bacitracin (in Polysporin): Named Allergen of the Year in 2003, with allergic reaction rates as high as 24% (JAAD). It’s been linked to over 12 cases of anaphylaxis.
- Neomycin (in Neosporin and Polysporin): Named Allergen of the Year in 2010, with allergic reactions in up to 30% of users (DermNet). It’s also ototoxic, meaning it can cause hearing loss when used on ears or ulcers. Manufacturers limit its use to 1 g/day for 7 days, but this is often exceeded.
3. They Fuel Antibiotic Resistance
Overusing topical antibiotics contributes to antibiotic-resistant bacteria, a growing global health threat:
- One study referenced in another meta-analysis, according to the National Institutes of Health (NIH), reported high levels of neomycin and bacitracin resistance, at 42.6% and 100% respectively, in Staphylococcus aureus isolates from patients with eczema. (PubMed).
- These products are also linked to the rise of community-acquired MRSA (methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus) (PubMed).
4. They Disrupt Your Skin’s Microbiome
Your skin is home to beneficial bacteria that aid healing and reduce inflammation. Topical antibiotics indiscriminately kill both harmful and helpful microbes, potentially delaying recovery and disrupting your skin’s natural balance.
But Aquaphor Isn’t the Answer
Aquaphor is a popular choice, blending petroleum with lanolin alcohol. While it’s occlusive (preventing water loss from the skin), the lanolin in Aquaphor can be problematic, especially for healing skin.
Lanolin, derived from sheep sebum, is generally safe for intact skin. But ointments like Aquaphor are typically used on wounds, burns or eczema—where lanolin’s risks become clear:
- A study of 1,012 children with eczema found 66% reacted to lanolin alcohol (Contact Dermatitis, 2017).
- Another study reported 17% of patients with chronic wounds had lanolin allergies (PubMed).
- A 2013 study found 52% of Aquaphor-treated wounds showed redness, compared to only 12% with plain Vaseline (J Drugs Dermatol).
Vaseline: A Safe, Effective Baseline
Plain Vaseline (white petrolatum) is a a safer option for a number of reasons:
- Low risk of allergy: Unlike Neosporin or Aquaphor, Vaseline rarely causes reactions.
- Proven performance: Multiple studies show Vaseline performs as well as or better than antibiotic ointments in preventing infection and supporting healing after dermatologic procedures (JAAD).
- Affordable and accessible: It’s a simple, cost-effective option for most wounds.
However, Vaseline has a limitation—it sits on the skin’s surface, offering occlusive protection but not actively penetrating to aid deeper recovery. It is not biodegradable and is comes from fossil fuels.
Doctor Rogers Restore Healing Balm: The Superior Choice
For those seeking a more advanced, effective, and sustainable option, Doctor Rogers Restore Healing Balm is the clear winner. Developed with just three plant-derived, hypoallergenic ingredients, it is:
- Clinically proven: A trial showed it heals skin faster than Aquaphor, with 90% of patients preferring it (PubMed).
- Petroleum-free, vegan and fragrance-free.
- Able to penetrate the skin supporting faster healing than petroleum based alternatives.
- Used nationwide by dermatologists for post-procedure care.
Doctor Rogers Healing Balm is ideal for sensitive skin, allergy-prone patients or anyone wanting a safer alternative to petroleum-based products.
Before and Afters:
What to Do if You Suspect Infection
If your wound shows signs of infection—redness, swelling, warmth, or discharge—skip the antibiotic ointments. Instead, use Hibiclens (chlorhexidine gluconate), an over-the-counter antimicrobial cleanser trusted in healthcare settings. It effectively kills bacteria without the allergy or resistance risks of Neosporin.
How to Care for Your Wound: A Simple, Proven Routine
Your skin is designed to heal itself—it just needs the right support. Follow these steps:
- Clean gently with soap and water or Hibiclens if infection is a concern.
- Pat dry with a clean towel.
- Apply Doctor Rogers Restore Healing Balm or plain Vaseline to keep the wound moist and protected as the skin cells heal.
- Cover with a clean bandage and change daily.
Avoid Neosporin, Polysporin, or triple-antibiotic ointments—they don’t speed healing and have increased risks of unwanted complications
Keep Things Simple
Wound care doesn’t need to be complicated. Neosporin and Aquaphor may seem like go-to solutions, but their risks—allergies, antibiotic resistance, and microbiome disruption—make them less than ideal. Plain Vaseline is a safe, effective baseline, while Doctor Rogers Restore Healing Balm offers a superior, hypoallergenic option for faster healing and happier skin.
Give your skin what it needs to thrive, and skip the products that make healing harder than it should be.
All product recommendations on this site are not sponsored and reflect the independent opinion of Dr. Heather D. Rogers, MD, based on her evidence-based research and extensive clinical experience as a practicing dermatologist. Links are provided for your convenience. Some may include discounts or commissions. Please shop wherever works best for you.
To receive expert, educational skincare insights from Dr. Rogers each week, sign up HERE.
The content on doctorrogers.com and our social media channels - including articles, blogs, videos, newsletters, and linked resources - is intended for general educational purposes only. It does not constitute medical advice, establish a doctor-patient relationship, or replace consultation with your physician. Use of this information and any recommended products is at your own risk and signifies your agreement with our Terms and Conditions. Nothing shared is intended to diagnose or treat specific medical practice.